1. Program notes on the B Minor Mass by Douglas Bush
In 1817 the Swiss critic Hans-Georg Naegeli praised Bach's Mass in B Minor
as "the greatest work of music in all ages and of all people." Though
some may wish to qualify Naegeli's statement, the Mass is one of the greatest
monuments in western art music. This notwithstanding, there are some intriguing
considerations when viewing the Mass from a historical perspective.
In contrast to its present fame, the work was largely unknown well into
the nineteenth century. Its delayed reception by later generations was
perhaps the result of the general unavailability of a score (Beethoven
tried unsuccessfully on several occasions to obtain a copy of the Mass).
The first published edition appeared in 1845, with a second and improved
edition appearing in 1856 as the sixth volume in the newly-formed Bach
Gesellschaft's publication of Bach's complete works.
Although most Mass settings stem from the Roman Catholic tradition, the
Mass in B Minor originated within the Lutheran liturgy. While Luther had
sought to reform points of doctrine, he did not oppose the liturgy of
the Roman Church. His Formula missae of 1523 retained the five
musical portions of the Latin Mass Ordinary Ü that is, the Kyrie, Gloria,
Credo, Sanctus (with Osanna and Benedictus), and Agnus Dei. In his Deutsche
Messe of 1527 Luther provided an alternative German vernacular mass,
but he seems to have considered the Latin Mass a higher form of worship.
The immense dimensions of the B Minor Mass render it virtually unusable
within the liturgical rites of either the Roman or Protestant churches.
Even in Bach's day, when the main church services lasted approximately
three hours, there would have been insufficient time to perform a work
of this scope (the sermon alone usually lasted more than an hour). Bach
worked on the Mass over a period of more than fifteen years (1733-1749),
collecting, revising, and composing new music that would provide a "summa"
of artistic achievement in his sacred vocal music, one that would unite
his creed as a Christian with his creed as a musician. The resulting work
represents an anthology of Bach's finest vocal music and at once displays
all the variety and beauty of his instrumental writing. Part III of the
Clavier-Uebung, published in 1739 and containing a collection of
organ works of the highest quality, was dedicated to "the spiritual delectation
of the lovers and, especially, the connoisseurs of this kind of work."
This seems to have been Bach's purpose in the Mass in B Minor as well.
With mounting perplexity pertaining to his position as the Cantor of St.
Thomas Church in Leipzig, Bach wrote a letter (dated 27 July 1733) to
the new Elector of Saxony, Friedrich August II, stating: "In deepest Devotion
I present to your Royal Highness this trifling product of that science
which I have attained in Musique..." Seeking to secure the patronage of
the Elector, the "trifling product" proffered was a beautifully prepared
presentation score for a Missa, comprising the Kyrie and Gloria sections
of what is now known as the Mass in B Minor. This pair of movements joined
four other such settings, in the keys of A, G, G Minor, and F. In Lutheran
worship the Kyrie-Gloria Mass was the preferred norm.
It appears that towards the end of the 1740s Bach became interested in
completing a "Missa tota", setting the complete text of the Mass Ordinary.
Bach's large-scale plan for a complete Mass setting can already be seen
in the structure of the Kyrie-Gloria Mass of 1733. This is evident not
only in the five-part choral writing or in the large orchestral forces,
but especially in the expansive and varied structure of the individual
movements. The three sections of the Kyrie typify the variety characterizing
the entire Mass. The initial "Kyrie eleison" seems to bear a similarity
to the opening of the St. John Passion, perhaps representing the imploring
multitudes of humanity in an urgent plea for mercy. The opening massive
chords are followed by an expansive fugue with an obligato orchestral
part. The "Christe eleison" employs the modern operatic duet style. The
duet may also refer to Christ as the second member of the Trinity and
to the duality of his divine and human natures. The final "Kyrie eleison"
tends towards the older style of vocal polyphony, therefore dispensing
with independent orchestral accompaniment. Not only are these three movements
greatly differentiated in style and compositional technique, they also
establish the sequence of the keys of B minor, D major and F-sharp minor,
thus unfolding the broad harmonic frame of the whole.
The Gloria continues the stylistic diversity of the Kyrie, and in addition
to four large choral movements ("Gloria in excelsis Deo"/"Et in terra
pax"; "Gratias agimus tibi"; "Qui tollis peccata mundi"; "Cum Sancto Spiritu")
contains four equally large solo or duet movements accompanied by obligato
instruments (violin, flute, oboe, and horn) and orchestra. Thus the Kyrie-Gloria
Mass of 1733 is musically complete in itself, all five voices having a
solo and each different group in the orchestra having an obligato part.
The "Symbolum Nicenum" or Credo, added to the score in the years 1748-49,
consists of nine movements. Originally there had been only eight movements,
the "Et in unum Dominum" movement also contained the words "Et incarnatus
est." But after the completion of the "Symbolum Nicenum," possibly even
after the completion of the entire score, Bach wrote a separate movement
for this latter segment of the text, likely making this the last vocal
composition he ever wrote. The nine movement structure of this section
is architecturally symmetrical: at the beginning and end a pair of choral
movements form a frame ("Credo in unum Deum," having a liturgical chant
melody or cantus firmus, and "Patrem omnipotentem"; these two opening
choruses correspond to "Confiteor unum baptisma," lso having a cantus
firmus, and "Et expecto" at the conclusion of the "Symbolum"). Two solo
movements stand next to these outer framing sections, while three choral
movements stand in the center, underlining the Christological nucleus
of the Credo ("Et incarnatus est" [And was incarnate]; "Crucifixus" [And
he was crucified]; "Et resurrexit tertia die" [And rose again on the third
day]).
Bach seemed to have a particular interest in numerology, a system of occultism
(hidden or concealed meaning) built around numbers. Each letter of the
word "Credo" was assigned a number according to its respective position
in the alphabet Ü hence C=3, R=17, E=5, D=4, and O=14, the total sum of
the numbers equaling 43 (i and j having the same number since they were
interchangeable in eighteenth-century German). Interestingly, there are
43 entries of the plainsong melody. Further, there are 45 measures in
the first Credo section, and 84 measures in the "Patrem omnipotentem"
totaling 129 measures, or 3 times 43, thus giving a threefold repetition
of the Credo number. This reflects the textual meaning of "Credo in unum
Deum" (I believe in one God), so that the reference is to the Holy Trinity,
Father, Son and Holy Ghost. Bach scribbled the number 84 in the autograph
score, 84 being the sum of 7 times 12 (the holy number of the church multiplied
by the number of the apostles), obviously concerned with the number of
measures in the second Credo.
The Sanctus and the following pieces also belong to the 1748-49 completion
of the Mass, but nearly all have earlier origins. The Sanctus had been
written for Christmas in 1724, in an easily alterable version for three
sopranos, alto, tenor, and bass. The "Osanna" is the only double choir
movement in the Mass, and it is a remodeling of the opening chorus from
the secular cantata No. 215. The Benedictus is perhaps a reworking of
a lost piece. The Agnus Dei also began as a parody of an older movement
from the Ascension Oratorio (BWV 11), but in addition to radical alterations
of the original material, it contains extensive newly composed sections.
The concluding "Dona nobis pacem" repeats the music of the "Gratias agimus
tibi" section, thus emphasizing the composer's conception of this section
being an expression of gratitude.
As Bach grew older, the Mass in B Minor must have seemed to him to be
a bequest to his successors and to the future. His primary interests now
lay in the pursuit of "musical art and science," and the fulfillment of
the scholar-composer's obligation to formulate a summary of his work.
The Mass encapsulates as does no other composition Bach's choral artistry
Ü it is the "summa" of all his sacred music. It offers a compositional
spectrum whose breadth and depth reveal both academic and spiritual penetration.
A complex system of thought at many levels went into the creating of this
great Mass. It seems to exemplify in every detail Bach's statement that
"the final aim and reason of all music is nothing other than the glorification
of God and the refreshment of the human spirit."
|
2. George Stauffer - "The
Universality of the B Minor Mass"
Although we may not be able to pinpoint Bach's specific reason for writing
a Missa tota, we can be reasonably sure that in turning to the Latin
Ordinary for his last large-scale project, he wished to devote his final
energies to music that would transcend the parochialism of his German-texted
vocal pieces. As Bach must have realized toward the end of his life, his
German-texted vocal works were local fare, based on libretti by town poets
and aimed at are rites and celebrations. Removed from their original contexts,
the pieces lost much of their meaning. In 1753 Caspar Ruetz, Kantor of the
Marienkirche in Luebeck, described how a huge pile of church music he had
inherited from his predecessors has been diminished by half from its use
for stove fires and scrap paper. "Who would give anything for it," he lamented,
"other than someone who needs scrap paper, since nothing is more useless
than old music." Surely Bach was aware that vast quantities of music suffered
this fate, especially vocal works with circumscribed utilty. One can imagine
him sitting in his study in the late 1740s, sullenly scrutinizing the 350
or so German-texted vocal pieces he had labored so diligently to produce
and realizing that the entire lot might be consigned to flames or the scrap
paper pile after his death.
The Latin Ordinary offered an alternative. Its text was universal, unbound
by day, event, or location. It was a public, not private, proclamation,
with Biblical citations removed from their incident-specific contexts and
transported to a more generalized realm. The opening lines of the Gloria,
connected with Christ's birth in the Book of Luke, are transformed into
an ecstatic hymn of praise in the Ordinary. The words of the Sanctus, spoken
by Isaiah in the Old Testament, become a broad, congregational affirmation.
Writing a Mass gave Bach the opportunity to transfer his endeavors from
the Lutheran Proper to the Catholic Ordinary, from the specific to the universal.
In the half-century following his death, it was the B Minor Mass that traveled
to Vienna and London, not his German-texted cantatas. "The Great Catholic
Mass" presented the possibility of geographical and historical transcendence.
The project also allowed Bach to survey his own vocal composition, from
the first mature cantatas of Weimar (the "Crucifixus," from Cantata 12),
to the five Leipzig church cycles of the 1720s (the "Qui tollis," from Cantata
46 or the "Patrem Omnipotentem," from Cantata 171), to the galant
Collegium pieces of the 1730s (the "Osanna," from BWV Anh. 11), and finally
to the Latin-texted studies of the final years (the "Credo"). It also gave
him the opportunity to draw on music written for church (Cantatas 46, 171),
for bureaucratic rituals (Cantatas 29, 120), and for ceremonial events (Cantatas
BWV Anh. 9, BWV Anh. 11, and the wedding serenade Auf! suessentzuckende
Gewalt). Whether or not it was the goal of the work, the Mass does represent
a Bach "specimen book," as Wolff put it, a highly select sampling of vocal
music culled from four decades of sacred and secular composition.
Then, too, the parody procedure gave Bach a final chance to rework and refine
his earlier scores. Bach's first biographer, Johann Nikolaus Forkel, expressed
delight in the composer's ability to make "little by little, the faulty
good, the good better, and the better perfect." In the B Minor Mass, we
find the type of perfection that appears in the skillful parody revisions
of the 1730s and 1740s. But there is something else. During the revisional
process Bach normally expanded preexisting material, embellishing lines,
thickening textures, adding measures, composing new sections. His indefatigable
inventiveness seemed to propel him in that direction. The opening movement
of the Concerto in A Minor, BWV 1044 (fifty-one measures longer than its
harpsichord prelude original), Contrapunctus 10 from the Art of Fugue (twenty-two
measures longer than its original), or the parody movement "Sicut erat in
principio" from the Gloria in excelsis Deo (six measures longer than
its "Cum Sancto Spiritu" original) are typical examples of his tendency
to enlarge.
In the B Minor Mass, Bach moved in the opposite direction, toward concision.
The "Osanna in excelsis" is thirty-three measures shorter than its model
(the "A" section of the chorus "Es lebe der Koenig"), the "Agnus Dei" thirty
measures shorter than its model (the aria "Entfernet euch, ihr kalten Herzen"),
the "Qui tollis" fifteen measures shorter than its model (the chorus "Schauet
doch und sehe, ob irgend ein Schmerz sei"). In many cases, the succinct
character of the Latin text and the sectional nature of a Mass setting called
for torsos rather than full movements. No matter what the motivation, however,
in making abridgments Bach not only rescued some of his best "old music":
he also distilled it. The B Minor Mass is more than a cross-section of Bach's
art. It is his art in highly concentrated form.
The synthesis of styles also contributes to the universality of the B Minor
Mass. At the outset of the Baroque Era, Monteverdi effectively demonstrated
the potential of stylistic pluralism Ü the idea that composers should use
both the a capella [without instruments] writing of the sixteenth
century and the
filled [with instrumental backup]
writing of the seventeenth Ü in the Vespers Collection of 1610. The Vespers
Collection is just that, however: a collection of independent liturgical
pieces illustrating the various stylistic possibilities of the time. The
B Minor Mass, which might be viewed as Bach's answer to the Vespers of
1610, goes beyond Monteverdi's principles. It is a true "reunion des gouts"
(to play on Francois Couperin's term of 1724), a true joining of tastes,
in which ancient and modern; Italian, French, and German; vocal and instrumental
are amalgamated in a single continuous work. Styles are sometimes juxtaposed,
as in "Credo" or "Confiteor," in which a Renaissance chorus and a Baroque
walking bass are combined. Other times they are placed side by side, as
in the operatic "Christe eleison" and the Palestrina-style "Kyrie" II.
Yet as we have seen, he work has overarching organizational bonds that
fuse the movements into a harmonius whole. The inclusive eclecticism of
the B Minor Mass, with its blending of diverse elements, points to the
cosmopolitan idiom Ü and Enlightenment ideals Ü of the Classical Era.
Furthermore, the B Minor Mass has a directness that counterbalances the
complexity of Bach's writing. The key scheme is unusually straightforward
for a large-scale vocal work. The emergence of and eventual dominance
of D major after the dark B minor/F# minor opening produces a sensation
of triumph not unlike the apotheosis that takes place in Beethoven's minor
key symphonies. The instrumental band of the B Minor Mass has a distinctly
modern cast, with a four-part Italian string body and pairs of woodwinds
Ü two flutes, two oboes (aside from the "Sanctus"), and (presumably) two
bassoons Ü that point forward to the late-eighteenth-century public ensemble
of Haydn's "London" Symphonies. With the exception of the oboe d'amore,
Bach avoided the colorful specialized instruments found in many of his
earlier vocal works. The absence of recitative, too, contributes to the
broad appeal of the B Minor Mass. The text and music do not address personalized
emotions, the role of recitative in Bach's cantatas. Rather, they speak
more generally, in public terms. In place of recitative, the "formless
form" of the Baroque, Bach employed strong, unambiguous structures: fugue,
da capo, motet, ritornello, ground bass. The architectural clarity of
each movement adds to the directness of the whole.
The presence of dance and dance-like idioms further broadens the appeal
of the B Minor Mass. As Doris Finke-Hecklinger has shown, Bach's attraction
to dance music began in earnest in he Coethen years, when galant
dances first appeared in substantial numbers in his secular cantatas.
The B Minor Mass is permeated with dance: the giga- or gigue-related nature
of the "Gloria in excelsis Deo" and "Qui sedes," the passepied qualities
of the "Pleni sunt coeli" and "Osanna," the rejouissance character
of the "Et resurrexit," the passacaglia bass pattern of the "Crucifixus,"
the pastoral hues of the "Et in Spiritum Sanctum," and the gavotte-like
rhythms of the "Et expecto" point to a work that is very much a part of
the present world. Bach used the secular to portray the sacred, and in
so doing he lifted both to an all-embracing plane. His repeated use of
chamber meters Ü 3/8 in the "Gloria," "Pleni sunt," and "Osanna" and 6/8
in the "Qui sedes" and "Et in spiritum" in particular Ü shows that he
was attuned to the growing appeal of light, galant instrumental
dances and did not hesitate to draw on their persuasive power.
Indeed, much of the attraction of the B Minor Mass comes from the instrumental
nature of Bach's writing. Thrasybulos Georgiades has reasoned that as
Mass settings evolved from the Middle Ages to the Baroque Era, they moved
from a literal reiteration of the text to a more ambiguous interpretation.
In the Middle Ages, the monophonic lines of plainchant reflected Latin
speech patterns. In the Renaissance, chant was retained in polyphonic
settings and used as the basis for composition, but it was objectified
Ü that is, placed into a mensural rhythm. With the advent of concerted
settings in the Baroque, the text of the Mass Ordinary was further distanced
from its speech origins and placed in a fully instrumental context. Taking
the "Et incarnatus" from the B Minor Mass as an example, Georgiades argues
that its depth of expression goes far beyond normal Baroque text settings.
The "Et incarnatus" expresses the inexpressible because Bach created music
that serves as symbol, symbol not specifically tied with speech. The opening
instrumental figure not only outlines in advance the general shape of
the vocal theme, but establishes the Affekt of the entire movement,
an Affekt of mystery and wonder. Thus the instrumental writing
determines the outcome of the setting, even though the setting is highly
vocal in nature.
One can easily point to other examples: although the fugue theme of "Kyrie"
I reflects the rhythmic declamation of the word "Kyrie", the melody itself
is strongly instrumental, with leaps that do not come naturally to the
voice. Indeed, the piece initially proceeds for twenty-nine measures in
a purely instrumental manner. When the voices enter..., they add complexity
and expressiveness to the movement. But the Affekt has been set
by the instrumental band. In the "Gloria," the opening instrumental fanfare
establishes the atmosphere of triumph before the voices are heard. The
instrumental parts in the "Gloria" could well stand alone, a fact which
led Smend to propose that the music stemmed from an instrumental concerto.
Even in Palestrina-style movements we find that Bach uses instrumental
lines to ameliorate the severity of the vocal counterpoint: violin parts
and a walking bass line in the "Credo," a walking bass in the "Confiteor,"
a battery of trumpets and timpani in the "Gratias" and "Dona nobis pacem,"
and an independent continuo part in "Kyrie" II.. The stile antico
[antique-style] preludes of Clavieruebung III, written ten years
earlier, are much more austere. They are more strongly modal and without
instrumental additions Ü "unsympathetically old-fashioned," as Peter Williams
has put it. The a capella movements of the B Minor Mass are different.
Bach has enriched the [older] Palestrina idiom with Baroque instrumental
counterpoint.
All of this contributes greatly to the Mass's universal appeal. The intense
instrumentalization of the score gives the work an attractiveness that
goes beyond its text and helps to account for its success in the concert
hall as well as the church, before listeners who know no Latin. Wilfrid
Mellers credits the remarkable impetus of the music to its linear energy
and "rhythmic ecstasy." The forward drive comes from the instrumental
character of Bach's writing.
In the B Minor Mass, Bach realized the full potential of the Neapolitan
idiom Ü the same idiom that gave birth to the enduring instrumental form
of the Classical Era. Surveying the significance of Beethoven's symphonies
in 1813, the well-known writer and critic E. T. A. Hoffmann praised instrumental
music as the highest art, because "scorning every aid, every admixture
of another art (the art of poetry)," it "gives pure expression to musicÍs
specific nature." This is a Romantic view, of course, and Hoffmann praised
Beethoven's instrumental music most of all because it opened a realm "of
the monstrous and the immeasurable." Bach's "Great Catholic Mass," with
its strong instrumental foundation, does not open the realm of the monstrous.
It does, however, transport the Latin Ordinary to the realm of the immeasurable. 3. John Butt, from Bach: Mass in B Minor Counterpoint and fugue are often the first things that the music of J. S. Bach calls to mind. Yet while it is extremely important to recognise BachÍs remarkable achievements in the field of counterpoint, it is perhaps a mistake to give these first priority in a broader analysis of his work. Counterpoint remained the primary compositional procedure of BachÍs age (whether studied or practised in its strictest form or in the shorthand of figured bass) and constitutes the basic fabric of all compositions, however chordal or "harmonic" they may appear. Therefore counterpoint and fugue itself were techniques rather than forms: the means of passing from one note or conglomeration of notes to the next, the means of controlling and displaying the principal thematic material, the inventio. Certainly many works of BachÍs may be described as fugues, but the relevance of fugal procedure to the structure as a whole is often only local. For instance the Kyrie of the Mass in B Minor is a large-scale ritornello movement as well as a fugue, so an analysis purely in terms of fugal process would necessarily be superficial.
Nevertheless, counterpoint is the next focal point in this study, standing as it does between the larger formal principles which influence the structure of individual movements, and the motivic detail of the instrumental and vocal lines. Many elements of BachÍs compositional style will emerge that are already familiar: the sense of proportion, economical use of the material, and the subtle frustration of expectation. A study of counterpoint also addresses the question of BachÍs historical position and his own attitude towards older styles and techniques.
As a product of the Lutheran musical environment of Thuringia, Bach would automatically have assimilated the standard compositional procedures of the late seventeenth century. The background to all styles would still have been the "strict" counterpoint of the late sixteenth century, but this had been greatly modified by the freedoms established with the Italian seconda prattica and also by the principle of the figured bass. This tended to reduce the contrapuntal integrity of the inner voices, thus emphasising the melodic importance of the outer ones. Throughout the Baroque era theorists and composers tended to temper the degree of freedom introduced according to the function of the music (chamber and dramatic music were respectively freer than church music), and Bach would always have been familiar with the stricter contrapuntal style traditionally associated with church music. However this residue of the Renaissance style was essentially "second hand", seen through the eyes of tradition and the ruling stylistic assumptions. BachÍs study of the stile antico proper represents a conscious desire to imitate the sixteenth-century models themselves.
Christopf Wolff's thorough examination of Bach's assimilation of the stile antico shows that he began to imitate the style in the early 1730s, after having already written the bulk of the Leipzig cantatas. The first significant product of BachÍs attempts was the second "Kyrie" of the Missa (1733 Ü but the music might be older), the last being the "Credo in unum Deum" and "Confiteor" of the Symbolum Nicenum. Although recent revisions to the chronology and the recognition of composing score in the "Confiteor" modify WolffÍs opinion that BachÍs study of the ancient style was complete by the early 1740s, it still seems that the Mass constitutes the focal point of BachÍs activity in this field and that the manuscript collection of sixteenth-century polyphony might have been assembled with this project in mind. Clearly the high profile of the stile antico in the Mass as a whole shows that Bach was making a conscious effort to incorporate all the styles that were available to him, to encompass all music history as far as is was accessible. In this respect it has much in common with the third part of the Clavieruebung (1739), which similarly comprises an anthology (and cycle) of music derived from the liturgy, covering all available historical styles, and having no practical function as a single work...
The studied neutrality of BachÍs stile antico is often juxtaposed with music of a strikingly expressive style. Just as the setting Kyrie, Gott heiliger Geist BWV 671 from Clavieruebung III concludes with an unexpected chromatic coda, alluding to the human plea of "eleison" (have mercy), the "Confiteor" ends with an intensely chromatic bridge, one of the most remarkable examples of its kind. While the integrity of the part-writing and chromaticism are not foreign to the madrigal style of the late sixteenth century, this passage is essentially tonal in its background structure. Indeed its enharmonic progressions seem to stretch Ü rather than predate Ü tonal conventions. This section contrasts the more strongly with the stile antico portion, shooting off the scale of Baroque expressive vocabulary. Here the effect is not one of emotion, rather one which seems to complement the sheer mystery of the statement "and I expect the resurrection of the dead", something which contrasts both with the joy of the succeeding music (to the same text) and the timeless doctrine of "one baptism for the forgiveness of sins", which precedes it.
|
Comments
Post a Comment
Please leave a comment. I appreciate your feedback. Thanks!